For many vacation rental managers, pricing decisions still come down to gut feeling: "Raise rates in high season, drop them in slower season, and hope for the best." But in today's competitive short-term rental (STR) landscape, guesswork isn't enough. To maximize revenue, managers need to lean on benchmarking and performance metrics that turn raw booking data into actionable insights.

Why Benchmarking Matters

Benchmarking simply means comparing your portfolio's performance against relevant standards, whether that's your past results, similar properties in your market, or broader industry trends. Without it, you may not even realize that you're underperforming.

For example:

• Is 65% occupancy "good"? Not if your comps are at 78%.

• Is your ADR (Average Daily Rate) strong? Not if you're leaving $30 per night on the table compared to similar listings nearby.

Benchmarking helps you move from intuition to evidence-based decisions.

Key Metrics Every STR Manager Should Track

Here are the foundational metrics that matter most:

• ADR (Average Daily Rate): Total revenue divided by nights sold.

• RevPAR (Revenue per Available Rental): Total revenue divided by all available nights (booked or not).

• Occupancy Rate: Nights booked divided by nights available.

• Booking Curve: How far in advance reservations are typically made.

• Seasonality Patterns: Understanding demand spikes and lulls in your market.

Together, these metrics tell the real story of your portfolio's health and revenue potential.

How to Compare Against Comps

To benchmark effectively, you need to identify "like-for-like" comparisons:

• Location: Same neighborhood or market.

• Property type & size: A 2-bedroom condo should be compared to other 2-bedroom condos, not luxury villas.

• Amenities: Pools, pet-friendliness, or high-speed Wi-Fi can all change guest willingness to pay.

Data can be collected from OTA dashboards, third-party analytics tools, or market intelligence features.

Reporting Cadence & Actionable Insight

Numbers only matter if you review them regularly and act on what you find. A recommended cadence:

• Weekly: Monitor occupancy and pricing adjustments.

• Monthly: Review ADR, RevPAR, and cancellation rates.

• Quarterly: Benchmark against comps and evaluate seasonality strategies.

Ask yourself: "What's one change I can make this week based on the data?" Then measure the results.

The CiiRUS Advantage

CiiRUS equips managers with the tools needed to make data-driven revenue decisions:

• Performance dashboards showing ADR, RevPAR, occupancy, and booking curves at a glance.

• Market intelligence tools that compare your rates to nearby competition.

• Custom report exports so you can share clear insights with owners.

• Anomaly detection that flags unusual dips in booking pace or revenue.

With CiiRUS, benchmarking isn't just possible, it's practical and built into your daily workflow.

Red Flag vs. Green Flag Scenarios

• Red flag: Your occupancy is 20% lower than the market, and your ADR is higher—you're overpriced and losing bookings.

• Green flag: Your ADR is slightly higher than comps, but occupancy is steady—you've positioned your property as premium without scaring away guests.

Tips for Using Data Effectively

1. • Test changes intentionally — adjust rates, policies, or amenities one at a time so you know what drives results.
   • Identify underperformers — don't assume all properties behave the same. Drill into individual listings that lag behind the portfolio.
   • Communicate with owners using data — charts and benchmarks build trust better than opinions.

Final Thoughts

Revenue management in STRs is no longer about instinct alone. By benchmarking against the right comps, tracking core metrics, and using tools like CiiRUS to visualize and act on data, managers can unlock revenue that might otherwise go unnoticed.

Data doesn't just show you where you are—it points the way to where you could be. With the right systems, every manager can move from guessing to growing.

‍